Every day we run The Narrative Machine on the past 24 hours of financial media to generate a list of the most linguistically-connected and narrative-central individual stories. We call this The Zeitgeist and we use it for inspiration or insight into short-form notes that we publish a couple of times a week to the website. To receive a free full-text email of The Zeitgeist whenever we publish to the website, please sign up here. You’ll get two or three of these emails every week, and your email will not be shared with anyone. Ever.
There has been a constant narrative undercurrent in the 2019 Zeitgeist we haven’t covered yet. The articles attached to the narrative have ranked highly nearly every day of the year, but never quite high enough to make our list of the top 5 most linguistically connected articles published by financial media on a given day. Today the topic broke through.
What is it?
The death of trucking.
An American trucking giant is slated to declare bankruptcy, and it may leave more than 3,200 truck drivers stranded and jobless [Business Insider]
Why did it finally break through to the top of our model’s attention? For a few reasons. First, a declared bankruptcy is a news event that will get mirrored coverage from multiple outlets. Second, the article links to prior pieces that covered an Amazon-specific angle, which it doesn’t take much prodding to discover is how, exactly, Amazon is the one killing it. But third, and most importantly, this article begins to shift the focus from a problem with the industry to a problem for workers. This transition alone, along with its attendant Fiat News and affect-laden language, connected this article to all sorts of political articles, opinion pieces expressing concern about the rise of left-populism among Democratic primary participants and the projected impact on markets, etc.
I suspect our readers will have wildly different views on whether the rapidly increasing propensity to frame business problems in context of their impact on labor is a good or bad thing. What matters, however, is that you know that it IS a thing, and that it is absolutely not going anywhere any time soon. It is a feature of the Widening Gyre, we think, that left populist and right populist language will dominate the narrative structure of nearly every conceivable social, political, economic or cultural topic for the foreseeable future. That is exactly what we are observing, even from Business Insider, and even on a subject as outside the mainstream of most Americans’ discussions as the prospects of a largely unknown trucking company.
In full disclosure, yes, I did pick the #2 most connected article over the #1 article so that I could post this with a picture of Large Marge. Plus I didn’t have anything to say about the Peleton Ad response (the #1 article in the Zeitgeist) that Aviation Gin didn’t already say.